NaNo Blogging Day #24: Bit by bit
Nov. 24th, 2008 05:32 pmAs expected, the going is still slow on the novel and progress has slowed to a crawl, because I'm just not concentrating that much on it. But it's my vacation and it's nearly Thanksgiving, and I don't feel guilty.
But I did do some thinking about my project and about writing in general on the way back from Massachusetts today. And one of the things I thought about was how writers are so constantly hammered with the old adage, "Show, don't tell". It's practically hammered into our heads by advice givers and fellow workshoppers from the moment we decide we have the temerity to both write and share that writing with others.
And a lot of things have bothered me about that little piece of wisdom, especially since writers are, ideally, storytellers.
Then it hit me that it's not so much that you should always show and never tell, but that there's a ratio of showing to telling in every story that either does or doesn't make the story work.
I think if you show and never tell, you end up with a really tedious story that describes in nauseating detail every little thing a character does. It's like trying to view a picture on a computer going pixel by pixel It doesn't work. You end up with what the people over at Flogging the Quill like to call "overwriting".
However, if you do nothing but tell, and never show, you end up with an overglorified outline.
So you need a balance. Some things merit showing, just as somethings in a movie warrant the camera zooming in. Some things, however, barely deserve mentioning. Opening doors, crossing the street, brushing teeth, getting dressed - you're better off just telling me that they happened and moving along to the interesting things like dragons and aliens and the plot.
The ratio, however, and what kind of telling and showing are sort of what learning to write is about. I don't know what they should be, but I know that different stories need different ratios. Some stories are all in the details, even the minor ones. Some stories are about broad strokes.
I hope I'm getting the right mix of showing and telling in what I'm doing now, and I definitely hope that readers (if any ever see this particular project) agree. But I suppose that's the point. To learn to get an intuitive sense of the balance of show and tell and make it work together, like rhythm and melody in a song.
Okay, enough of the metaphors. I got tacos waiting on me and a chapter to finish up. Library books have to be stolen and people have to be beat up and marriages have to be imperiled!
But I did do some thinking about my project and about writing in general on the way back from Massachusetts today. And one of the things I thought about was how writers are so constantly hammered with the old adage, "Show, don't tell". It's practically hammered into our heads by advice givers and fellow workshoppers from the moment we decide we have the temerity to both write and share that writing with others.
And a lot of things have bothered me about that little piece of wisdom, especially since writers are, ideally, storytellers.
Then it hit me that it's not so much that you should always show and never tell, but that there's a ratio of showing to telling in every story that either does or doesn't make the story work.
I think if you show and never tell, you end up with a really tedious story that describes in nauseating detail every little thing a character does. It's like trying to view a picture on a computer going pixel by pixel It doesn't work. You end up with what the people over at Flogging the Quill like to call "overwriting".
However, if you do nothing but tell, and never show, you end up with an overglorified outline.
So you need a balance. Some things merit showing, just as somethings in a movie warrant the camera zooming in. Some things, however, barely deserve mentioning. Opening doors, crossing the street, brushing teeth, getting dressed - you're better off just telling me that they happened and moving along to the interesting things like dragons and aliens and the plot.
The ratio, however, and what kind of telling and showing are sort of what learning to write is about. I don't know what they should be, but I know that different stories need different ratios. Some stories are all in the details, even the minor ones. Some stories are about broad strokes.
I hope I'm getting the right mix of showing and telling in what I'm doing now, and I definitely hope that readers (if any ever see this particular project) agree. But I suppose that's the point. To learn to get an intuitive sense of the balance of show and tell and make it work together, like rhythm and melody in a song.
Okay, enough of the metaphors. I got tacos waiting on me and a chapter to finish up. Library books have to be stolen and people have to be beat up and marriages have to be imperiled!